Why Is Alcoholism Considered a Disease, but Not Smoking? Are Food Addicts Considered Diseased?
Question by nunuvyobizniz: Why is alcoholism considered a disease, but not smoking? Are food addicts considered diseased?
Why would alcoholism not just be called an addiction like smoking or doing drugs? And if doing drugs is obviously worse and illegal than smoking, then why don’t we just call smoking a crutch? Or why don’t we call all smoking and drug addiction a disease as well? So, would food addicts also be considered diseased? Because it can be just as dangerous. Who made up these rules as to what’s a disease, what’s a crutch, and what’s an addiction?
Best answer:
Answer by Ginny Jin
well a disease is something that is spread or contagious or causes infection. Alcoholism is more of an illness.
Answer by raysny
Alcoholism became a disease only because the AMA voted it to be a disease at the urging of Marty Mann, former PR woman who successfully made Alcoholics Anonymous the favored method of treatment in the US.
http://www.roizen.com/ron/mann.htm
The most convincing argument for alcoholism/addiction being a disease
comes from Gorski:
“If alcoholism is defined as a disease, it will be treated as a healthcare problem. As a result, alcoholics will be assured the right to receive appropriate medical treatment for this disease. The treatment of Alcoholism will be covered by health insurance and other health care financing plans in both the public and private sectors. The appropriate health care groups will be mobilized to support its treatment. And, most importantly, ongoing biomedical research which relates alcoholism to other diseases will be funded.
If alcoholism is not defined as a disease, we will be making the decision that it does not rightfully belong within healthcare. Alcoholics, then, will be denied access to vital healthcare services.
Insurance and other health care financing plans will exclude alcoholism.
Alcoholism, which is responsible for 30% of all inpatient hospital days and nearly 50% of emergency room visits, will be divorced from the medical field. As a result it will never be fully integrated into our health care system.”
There it is, the ECONOMIC reason that alcoholism called “disease”.
Over the years, the definition of the word ‘disease’ changed so that it might include alcoholism.
Students face deadly effects of prescription drug addictions
While Tyler contends that drug abuse and addiction does not discriminate, Hersh argues that some are more vulnerable than others. “Drug addiction is a disease,” Hersh said. “For someone with a predisposition to addiction, you are prescribed that, there …
Read more on Miami Student
Grandmother asks Globe Santa for help
As anyone with a friend or loved one who has struggled with addiction can testify, perhaps even more painful than watching the terrific beating that alcohol and drugs administer to the user is the damage that the disease inflicts on those closest to …
Read more on Boston.com
Alzheimer's Gene Tied to Brain Changes at Early Age
People with a high-risk gene for Alzheimer's disease can begin to have brain changes as early as childhood, according to a new study. … The investigators then examined brain tissue from 189 dead people who had not had Alzheimer's, who ranged in age …
Read more on Newsday
Find More How Is Addiction Not A Disease Information…